I think it is up to personal preference.
I wanted to make the Ward La France nice but wasn't concerned about it being shiny. Yes, I gave it a coat of paint but that's because the French had painted various bits yellow and it would look very odd with some bits having new paint and other bits looking old and tired.
I was very happy with the end result but am just as happy with the wrecker looking dirty and greasy - as a wrecker should. However, if someone wants to portray a wrecker spotlessly clean - who am I to say it’s not correct. The REME vehicles were inspected just as thoroughly as other units vehicles.
I am amazed at the so called experts who say this and that is not correct. Who knows what went on in the field, unless of course you were a serving soldier at the time? Even then you could only say what you or your unit did during your service.
If you attempted a restoration of a high standard then I am in agreement it should look as it has just left the factory - otherwise what‘s the point in doing it in the first place! But that is my opinion - no one elses.
Likewise, people may choose to restore a vehicle to show a particular event or time such as The Bulge, Market Garden, etc.
When it comes to the public I would imagine they look at our restored vehicles as if they had just rolled out of the factory rather than seen active service.
Whatever way you restore your pride and joy, remember it is your vehicle and your choice. If someone doesn’t like it, tell them to …………………. and go bother someone who cares.
Markheliops