Jack you raise several very interesting points. I was recently party to a lengthy (heated) long running debate on another forum regarding WW2 history and Hollywood.
BoB was at the centre of the discussions. U 571, Kesserine Pass, Battle of the Bulge, Bridge too Far, Patton, Kelly’s Heroes, When Trumpets Fade, and (later) more recent events from 'Nam and Somalia, were all mentioned.
Now the thread in question started out as a simple uniform query, it turned into a slanging match. Why ? Well basically these films were being quoted as REFERENCE WORKS.
"I saw it in the film so it MUST be true" was a repeated comment.
I have a serious concern that these Hollywood portrayals of world events, AS GOOD AS THEY ARE, are often taken as fact, and are sometimes quoted as a source of reference material to History students, Re-enactors and Military History enthusiasts. The visual impression is powerful and we all want to believe that the Producers/Directors of these films did their own research and got it right. We all know that that isn't always the case.
Regrettably BoB also falls into this category. It is NOT historically accurate, and in fairness I don't this the film claimed too be, BUT it is now being quoted (sticking my neck out) by some re-enactors as being so.
It worries me that with the passing of time the visual images from these 'modern' works are taken as fact.
Kelly’s Heroes (sorry Oddball) relates to a real infantry unit, in a real theatre of operation, BoB also, U571 as well, the list goes on. There is an uncomfortable mix of fact and fiction and we are drawn into the belief that, because we can relate to the fact element, then the unknown fiction element may also be true.
Jack said; There is so much that the nation could learn from these films! Jack I regret the nation does learn from these films, but its not always the truth.
One trip to the local library and a read of a well researched book, will often put things in perspective. But hell we all like to take the easy route and sit in the comfort of a warm theatre with our popcorn and drinks, it’s so much more enjoyable.
Yes I do care.
Karoshi
Dons tin hat and dashes to bunker, waiting re enactor flaming.